MagicReply vs GatherUp
GatherUp sells review requests, replies, and add-ons for listings and review disputes. MagicReply drafts replies to Google reviews and can post them. They overlap on written replies and differ on everything else in GatherUp's price list. They are different kinds of tools.
We read the GatherUp pricing page on November 15, 2026. MagicReply figures come from our pricing page.
Every GatherUp figure on this page comes from https://gatherup.com/pricing/ as read on November 15, 2026, in USD. The $99 and $60 reputation prices are labeled "Billed annually". The page also says month-to-month plans have no annual commitment and that annual billing saves about 20 percent. It does not print a separate month-to-month dollar amount, so this page does not calculate one.
Reputation management, as printed
Local Businesses is $99 per month, billed annually, for 1 location. Multiple Locations is $60 per month per location, billed annually. Agency pricing is custom. The page says users are unlimited within a plan. Every core plan lists feedback and review requests, AI-crafted replies and in-app responding, Net Promoter Score and surveys, review monitoring across 100-plus sites, topic and keyword tagging, and a reporting suite. The longer feature list adds up to 300 SMS and 3,000 email credits per location per month, QR codes, custom feedback links, an API, Zapier, webhooks, review widgets and a badge, and automated social sharing.
A 14-day trial gives full access, asks for no credit card, and bills nothing until you continue. That trial is for GatherUp's paid product. It is not a free plan with a published $0 price.
Add-ons, and what MagicReply does not do
Listings Management is separate, at $40 per month per location. The page says one update publishes to 150-plus directories, and that 11 or more locations should contact them for volume pricing. Review Defense is also separate, and only with an annual commitment. Reveal is $45 per month per location, billed annually, and lists review analysis, a Transparency Certificate subject to approval, Review Insights, and daily activity notifications. Illuminate is $125 per month per location and adds automated review disputes and review analysis for up to 6 local competitors. Integrity is $300 per month per location and adds analysis for up to 15 competitors and automated disputes of competitor reviews. The page says the review platform makes the final removal decision and that no provider can promise removal.
MagicReply does not offer listings sync, review disputes, Net Promoter Score surveys, SMS credits, or social sharing of reviews. It drafts Google review replies. Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required. The Free plan is not a 14-day trial. The Free plan does not auto-reply. Auto-reply is on Pro and Business, and both include a 7-day trial. MagicReply sends a review-request email to one customer address at a time, on every plan. It does not send review requests by text, in bulk, or on a schedule.
GatherUp and MagicReply side by side
GatherUp column: their public page as read on November 15, 2026. MagicReply column: our pricing page and plan limits.
| Feature | GatherUp | MagicReply |
|---|---|---|
| Reputation management price (USD) | Local Businesses $99 per month, billed annually, for 1 location. Multiple Locations $60 per month per location, billed annually. Agency is custom. Month-to-month exists, with no separate dollar amount printed. | Free $0. Pro $19.99 per month. Business $49.99 per month. |
| Ways to start | A 14-day trial with full access and no credit card. Nothing bills until you continue. | A Free plan that is not a trial. Pro and Business include a 7-day trial. |
| Written replies | AI-crafted replies and in-app responding, listed on every core plan. | AI drafts on every plan. Free posts up to 5 to Google in total. Auto-reply is on Pro and Business only. |
| Review requests | Feedback and review requests on every core plan, with up to 300 SMS and 3,000 email credits per location per month. | Email on every plan, one customer address at a time. No texts, no bulk sends, and no schedule. |
| Listings | Listings Management is separate, at $40 per month per location, publishing to 150-plus directories. | Not offered. |
| Review disputes | Review Defense is separate and annual only. Reveal $45, Illuminate $125, Integrity $300, each per month per location, billed annually. The page says removal is not guaranteed. | Not offered. |
Questions this page answers
Other comparisons
Birdeye, Podium, Reputation.com, NiceJob, ChatGPT, Yext, BrightLocal . The comparison hub lists every page, and the alternatives page lists the tools together.
Draft a reply to one of your Google reviews
Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required. The Free plan does not auto-reply.