MagicReply vs BrightLocal
BrightLocal sells local SEO plans. Review responses are listed on the Grow plan, not as the whole product. MagicReply drafts replies to Google reviews and can post them. They are different kinds of tools.
We read the BrightLocal pricing page on November 15, 2026. MagicReply figures come from our pricing page.
Every BrightLocal figure on this page comes from https://www.brightlocal.com/pricing-page/ as read on November 15, 2026, in USD. The one-location prices below are the ones printed for a single location. The same page prints higher bands for more locations, and "Price on request" above 100 locations.
One location, as printed
For one location, Track is $41 USD per month billed monthly, or $369 USD billed annually, which the page shows as $31 per month. Manage is $54 USD per month billed monthly, or $485 USD billed annually ($40 per month). Grow is $65 USD per month billed monthly, or $584 USD billed annually ($49 per month).
Track lists local SEO audits, local ranking for up to 100 keywords and four competitors, a geo-grid for up to five keywords, citation accuracy, and a Google Business Profile audit. Manage lists everything in Track plus AI Insights, keeping business details synced across sites, and scheduling posts on Google Business Profile. Grow lists everything in Manage plus monitoring and responding to customer reviews across multiple sites, getting customer reviews via email, SMS, and in-store campaigns, and publishing customer reviews on your website. The "monitor and respond" line is printed under Grow. It is not printed under Track or Manage.
Other prices on the same page
Citation Builder is pay-as-you-go, not included in the plan price. The FAQ says citations start at $3.20 per site, or as low as $2 with bulk credits. A managed SEO service is listed at $1,299 USD per month. API access is listed as a custom price. The FAQ says they do not take card details upfront and that you pay when you are ready. It does not print a $0 plan. You can cancel. The FAQ says they will not delete your account or your reports, and that reports will not be accessible or update with new data after you cancel. A downgrade happens immediately, and they do not refund the remaining time on the current plan.
MagicReply does not offer local rank tracking, citation building, listing sync, or a managed SEO service. It drafts Google review replies. Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required. The Free plan does not auto-reply. Pro and Business include auto-reply and a 7-day trial. MagicReply sends a review-request email to one customer address at a time, on every plan. It does not send review requests by text, in bulk, or on a schedule, and it does not run in-store review campaigns.
BrightLocal and MagicReply side by side
BrightLocal column: their public page as read on November 15, 2026. MagicReply column: our pricing page and plan limits.
| Feature | BrightLocal | MagicReply |
|---|---|---|
| One location, monthly or annual (USD) | Track $41 per month, or $369 billed annually ($31 per month). Manage $54 per month, or $485 billed annually ($40 per month). Grow $65 per month, or $584 billed annually ($49 per month). | Free $0. Pro $19.99 per month. Business $49.99 per month. |
| Review responses | Grow lists "Monitor and respond to customer reviews across multiple sites". Track and Manage do not print that line. | AI drafts on every plan. Free posts up to 5 to Google in total. Auto-reply is on Pro and Business only. |
| Asking customers for reviews | Grow lists email, SMS, and in-store campaigns. Track and Manage do not print that line. | Email on every plan, one customer address at a time from the Review Link page. No texts, and no in-store campaign product. |
| Listings and Google posts | Manage and Grow list synced business details and scheduled posts on Google Business Profile. Track lists a Google Business Profile audit. | Not a listings product. Replies can be posted to Google reviews. Scheduling other Google posts is not offered. |
| Rank tracking | Track, and the plans that include Track, list local ranking for up to 100 keywords and four competitors. | Not offered. |
| Separate services | Citation Builder from $3.20 per site. Managed SEO at $1,299 USD per month. API at a custom price. No $0 plan is printed. | A Free plan that is not a trial. Pro and Business include a 7-day trial. None of those BrightLocal services are offered. |
Questions this page answers
Other comparisons
Birdeye, Podium, Reputation.com, NiceJob, ChatGPT, Yext, GatherUp . The comparison hub lists every page, and the alternatives page lists the tools together.
Draft a reply to one of your Google reviews
Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required. The Free plan does not auto-reply.