After a big storm, out-of-town crews work under names that sound like yours, and their customers sometimes review the wrong company. Search your contracts and estimates first. If nothing matches, say so in one sentence, ask for the address by phone, and flag the review.
Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required.
Storm crews are the most common source of a roofing review you cannot match. A crew rolls into town after hail, works for a few weeks, and leaves. Their unhappy customers search for a roofer, find you, and post. That is not a lie, but it is not your job either.
Search by the homeowner’s name, the phone number, and the street in both contracts and estimates. Some reviewers only got a quote. If you find an estimate but no job, the reply is about the estimate, not about a roof you never installed.
When nothing matches, the reply says you cannot find a job or an estimate under that name and asks them to call with the address. Do not put a street, a carrier, or a storm date in the reply.
Do not describe the other company or warn readers about storm chasers in the thread. It reads as a pitch. Flag the review and move on.
The reviews on this page are invented to show a reply shape. They are not quotes from a customer. For a single draft of a review you already have, use the free review reply generator. No account is required for that one reply.
Examples
A review meant for an out-of-town crew
Example review
“Crew showed up from out of state after the hail, took the deposit and disappeared. Avoid!”
Reply
We are sorry you went through this. We cannot find a contract or an estimate that matches this review, and we are a local company with our own crews. If we did work at your home, please call [Name] at [phone] with the address. We have flagged the review in our business profile.
[Your name], Owner
[phone]
Says what the company is without attacking another
Asks for the address by phone, not in the thread
A review about gutters you do not install
Example review
“Gutters pulled off the fascia in the first snow. Garbage install.”
Reply
Thank you for the note. We replace and repair roofs, and we do not install gutters, so we cannot match this review to a job. If we worked on your roof, please call [phone] and we will look it up. The review has been flagged.
[Your name], Office manager
[phone]
States the scope of work
Does not call the writer dishonest
Questions
Can we say the review came from a storm chaser’s customer?
No. You do not know who wrote it, and the accusation becomes the story. Say you cannot match it and flag it.
We gave them a quote and they hired someone else. Can we flag the review?
Only if it breaks Google rules. A person who got a quote can review the quote. Reply to that experience, and leave the job you did not do out of it.