A one-star roofing review is often about a leak that came back or a callback that never came. Apologize, give a person and a number, and keep the reply under four sentences. Leave the deductible and the claim out of it.
Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required.
A roof is one of the most expensive things a homeowner buys and never looks at. When it leaks after the job, the review is written with real fear. Answer the fear: say you are sorry, say someone will come look, and give the number.
Do not diagnose the leak in public. Flashing, a vent boot, an old skylight, or ice dams might each be the cause, and the reply is not the place to pick one. Saying it was not your work, before anyone has been on the roof, reads as a dodge.
One star after a door-knock sale is its own case. If the review says a rep promised a free roof through insurance, do not answer that in the thread at all. Apologize for the experience, give the owner’s number, and look hard at how your reps sell.
Do not ask for the rating to change once the leak is fixed. Fix it, and let the homeowner decide.
The reviews on this page are invented to show a reply shape. They are not quotes from a customer. For a single draft of a review you already have, use the free review reply generator. No account is required for that one reply.
Examples
A leak back after the first storm
Example review
“Roof leaked the first big rain after they finished. Ceiling stain in the bedroom. They will not call me back.”
Reply
We are sorry a leak showed up after the job and that you have not heard back. That is not acceptable. Please call me directly at [phone] and we will set a time to get someone on the roof.
[Your name], Owner
[phone]
The owner signs, because the callback failed
Does not guess the cause of the leak
A pushy pitch at the door after hail
Example review
“Salesman came to my door after the hail, said insurance would cover everything, then the bill came. Scam.”
Reply
Thank you for telling us. We are sorry about how this was presented to you at the door. Please call me at [phone]. I want to hear exactly what you were told.
[Your name], Owner
[phone]
Does not mention insurance, coverage, or the bill
Takes the sales complaint to the owner
Questions
Should we post photos of the finished roof to show it was done right?
No. A photo can show the house and the street, and it turns the reply into an argument. Offer an inspection on the phone.
What if the leak is from an old skylight we did not touch?
Say so on the call, after someone has looked. In public, the reply stays: we are sorry, here is a person, here is a number.