Guide

How to reply to a fake gym review

Gyms in the same chain, the same plaza, or with similar names get each other’s reviews all the time. Before calling a review fake, check whether it describes your floor. If it names a pool, a class, or a coach you do not have, say what you do have and ask them to call.

Free plan: generate up to 15 AI replies and post up to 5 to Google in total, no credit card required.

The tell for a misplaced gym review is usually an amenity: a pool when you have none, a 24-hour door when you close at 10, a spin class you do not run. Answer with that fact. It is about the gym, not the writer.

Franchise gyms have a special case. A member of another location in the same brand may review yours by mistake, since the map pins sit close together. Say which location this listing is for, and point them to the right one if you know it.

Do not post that the person "has never been a member here." You may be right, but membership is account information. Say you cannot match the review to this location and ask them to call.

Flag the review from your business profile. Then leave the thread alone. A second reply that argues with a follow-up comment does more harm than the review.

The reviews on this page are invented to show a reply shape. They are not quotes from a customer. For a single draft of a review you already have, use the free review reply generator. No account is required for that one reply.

Examples

A review about a pool you do not have

Example review

“Pool is always freezing and the lifeguard is on his phone. Disgusting.”

Reply

Thank you for the note. Our location does not have a pool, so this review may be meant for another gym nearby. If we can help with anything here, please call [Name] at [phone]. We have flagged the review. [Your name], General manager

  • States an amenity fact, not a membership fact
  • Allows for an honest mistake

A review meant for another club in the same brand

Example review

“Downtown location is always packed and the showers never work.”

Reply

Thank you for writing. This listing is for our [Neighborhood] location, not the downtown club. The downtown team can be reached at [phone]. If your note is about us, please ask for [Name] at the desk. [Your name], General manager

  • Points to the right location instead of arguing
  • Does not say whether the writer is a member

Questions

Can we check the door log and say they never scanned in?
Check it, but do not post it. A check-in log is account data. The public reply says you cannot match the review and asks them to call.
Should we report a review that is meant for another location?
Yes, from your business profile. Point the writer to the right location in your reply as well, since that often fixes it faster.

Reply to all your reviews automatically: Start Free

Reply to all your reviews automatically

Connect Google Business Profile and MagicReply drafts a reply for each review, ready for you to edit and post.